- Writers: Frank Darabont
- Stars: Alanna Masterson , Andrew Lincoln , Chandler Riggs , Christian Serratos , Danai Gurira , Emily Kinney , Josh McDermitt , Lauren Cohan , Laurie Holden , Melissa McBride , Michael Cudlitz , Norman Reedus , Sarah Wayne Callies , Scott Wilson , Sonequa Martin-Green , Steven Yeun
Daryl interrogates Randall about his group and he learns that they are formed by thirty dangerous men capable to rape two teenage daughters in front of their father. Rick and Shane decide to kill Randall, who is considered a threat to the survivors, but Dale opposes to their decision and Rick summons the group that is supportive to the execution to vote. Dale tries to convince each survivor that they must not lose their humanity. Carl is affected by the situation and has strange actions: first he sneaks to talk to Randall; then he disrespects Carol with an offensive comment about her beliefs; then he teases a walker that is trapped in the swamp; then he decides to participate in the meeting that will judge of Randall; and finally when Rick is ready to shoot Randall in the head, Carl arrives in the barn affecting Rick. Meanwhile Dale wonders on the field and is surprised by the walker that Carl had made fun of.