Alicia and Will once again face each other in court when they represent opposing clients in a dispute over a successful song. Tactics plays a role as much as the law as they both try to distract the other in court. Cary may have found a way for their clients to win but it's Robyn who saves the case. After hearing that Marilyn Garbanza is pregnant and intends to name her son Peter, Eli hires Kalinda to find out who the father is. What she finds points in the very direction Eli was hoping to stay away from. When Eli receives a call from an aggressive journalist he fears the worse - but the information in the journalist's hands is far worse than he could have imagined.