Detective Murdoch investigates the murder of Jeanette Rajotte who is found in the cemetery of her church at her parent's grave. Dr. Grace confirms that she died as a result of a blow to the head. Murdoch is pleased to see that his childhood mentor, Father Keegan, is visiting the parish and they begin to work together. The parish priest, Father Daniel Lebel, has gone missing and as far as Inspector Brackenreid is concerned he is their main suspect, though Murdoch is keeping an open mind. The dead woman worked at the parish as a cleaner and according to the priest's cook, Lebel was a good man. As Murdoch begins piecing it all together, it appears Father Keegan hasn't been entirely truthful with him.