Four years ago, in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, Dean and Sam are torturing a demon that possessed the postman Jeffrey and killed women in a farmhouse trying to find Lilith. Out of the blue, the Wiccan Nora Havelock that helped the Winchester brothers to find Jeffrey comes to the place to see the demon. Dean and Sam get the information and exorcise the demon, and they carry the wounded Jeffrey to a hospital. In the present days, Dean and Sam return to Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, to investigate the murder of several women. Dean meets Jeffrey that brings him to the demon hideout. Meanwhile Sam, who is seeing Lucifer everywhere, visits Nora and discovers a secret about the murders.