After four suspicious suicides, Dean and Sam investigate the cases and they discover that the suicidal victims have heard painful truths before their final act. Their further investigation shows another death that might have been suicide. They visit the victim's sister and they discover that she had invoked Veritas, the Goddess of Truth, who feeds of the victims of the truth. Soon Dean becomes her next victim and he uses his fate to question Sam about what has happened after his return from Hell. But when Veritas captures the Winchester brothers, they hear truths about each other.