- Writers: Whitney Cummings, Michael Patrick King
- Stars: Kat Dennings, Beth Behrs, Garrett Morris, Jonathan Kite
Max and Caroline finally open their cupcake shop. Max decides to use the opening as a way to get back at her exes so she invites all of them including Johnny. When she learns he didn't get married they hook up. She's happy. But Andy points out what is wrong with him.